Story image

Elon Musk: Tesla's market cap higher than they deserve

24 May 17

Tesla investors may be feeling alarmed at a comment from CEO Elon Musk last week. He said the company's "market cap is higher than we have any right to deserve" and that automotive company from the ground up is "the worst way to earn money, honestly."

This is classic Musk, who is knowing for being somewhat of a renegade when it comes to media obligations, and enjoys speaking off the cuff and keeps it generally pretty unscripted. In line with this, Musk displayed the same mentality when he said that he slept in a sleeping bag on the floor of the factory. Knowing "people were having a hard time, working long hours, and on hard jobs,” he tried to be more involved in the hands-on process.

When accused of putting production over the wellbeing of employees, Musk bit back.

“This is not some situation where, for example, we are just greedy capitalists who decided to skimp on safety in order to have more profits and dividends,” he says.

“It's just a question of how much money we lose. And how do we survive? How do we not die and have everyone lose their jobs?"

Financial analyst Ben Kallo of Robert Baird says Musk’s comments are highly unusual for someone of his position.

"In my experience, in over 10 years covering stocks and clean energy, I've never heard another CEO say that," he says.

It's not a first for Musk, either. Twice in 2013, following a big increase in the stock value, he said the value was higher than the company deserved. In 2014 he made a similar quip, saying "our stock price is kind of high right now to be totally honest."

Kallo thinks the most likely scenario is that Musk is trying to "temper expectations," as well as "be straightforward with the market and let people know they have a tough road ahead of them."

The company has said it intends to expand its production goals five-fold, from the 80,000 vehicles it produced last year to 500,000 in 2018.

"Usually a CEO is trying to do the opposite, especially when you have capital needs,” says Kallo.

Toni Sacconaghi, of Bernstein Research is doubtful that Musk was trying to send a deliberate message to investors.

"I chalk it up more to Elon's fairly unscripted nature. If you listen to Tesla earnings conference calls, Elon just starts with questions," he says.

"He says whatever's on his mind."

Of course, Musk isn't the only one who sees Tesla's share price, which closed Monday at US$310, as overvalued. Analysts who cover the company have a consensus price target of US$262, according to FactSet data provided by Baird.

Valve stops Steam Link hardware sales; promotes Android app instead
Valve announced that its supply of Steam Link hardware has sold out – and by the looks of it, it won’t be making any more.
Hands-on review: Spyro Reignited Trilogy brings back the PSOne icon
Spyro Reignited Trilogy is a great remake that features new school graphics with old fashioned style of gameplay.
Don't let criminals ruin your online shopping
It’s that time of year again. Not only have New Zealanders developed a bit of a taste for sales like black Friday and cyber Monday, the holiday season is well upon us.
Student app Niesh gets $1m funding windfall
“We’re a data driven company, and we’re using what we know to benefit students and the companies giving them rewards, discounts, and jobs,” explains co-founder Jae Yoo.  
NZ-grown fitness app draws on augmented reality
“I started working on creating an AR app over a year ago starting with just fitness. But as we moved on, it made sense to add in special features."
NZ's online merchants can now offer Google Pay
With Google Pay, customers will be able to speed through checkout with just a few clicks."
Hands-on review: Intel Core i7 8086K Limited Edition
Whilst I’ve seen commemorative coins and stamps, I’ve never seen a commemorative CPU. Intel’s Core i7 8086K is exactly that.
Hands-on review: Logitech G1 Pro Gaming Headphones and Mouse
For the serious gamer, this kit will have you happily spreading mayhem in glorious surround sound.