Story image

PaCT under fire again

12 Jul 2013

School principals rejected any further association with the development of a computerised assessment system, the Progress and Consistency Tool (PaCT), at their national conference in Hamilton this week.

Philip Harding, president of theNew ZealandPrincipals’ Federation says while the Minister of Education has made it clear that national tests are not conducive to children’s learning, by using PaCT to support national standards, it will do the same harm as a national test.

“Further, introducing PACT will do nothing to help our priority learners who are supposedly the target group of this government,” says Harding.

“We already know who these children are – why can’t we talk about their learning needs rather than foist a test on them so we can say yet again that their achievement results are poor.”

Meanwhile education union, NZEI Te Riu Roa, is also calling on political parties to oppose the PaCT, which is expected to become mandatory for all primary school students in 2015.

Judith Nowotarski, NZEI Te Riu Roa national president, says the PaCT tool would not fix dodgy and inconsistent National Standards.

Instead, it would harm children’s learning and quality teaching by narrowing the curriculum, cementing in invalid National Standards’ judgements about children’s achievement and de-professionalising teachers’ expertise and knowledge of students by forcing a reliance on one assessment tool.

She says it’s also concerning that by making the tool compulsory, the Government could rank individual schools or individual teachers based on student achievement.

“Teachers already know how well their students are doing. What they want is the ability to share new and effective teaching strategies and to access the specialist support many children that are struggling need," she says.

"The government needs to listen to the teaching profession and work with us to focus on how to lift student achievement, particularly amongst vulnerable children, rather than impose policies that have failed overseas.”

NZEI has already urged principals and teachers not to take part in PaCT trials being run by the Ministry of Education.

However, according to the Ministry of Education, initial feedback from teachers and principals on the tool has been positive.

The Ministry of Education this week demonstrated how the tool works and how it will support teachers and schools to the Education and Science Select Committee

It will be used by teachers, not students and has been developed in response to concerns about consistency. It helps teachers know how their students are progressing and what they might do next to support each student.

“National Standards rely on the professional judgment of teachers and PaCT is designed to support teachers to make those judgments. It is being developed with the teaching profession, for the teaching profession,” says Phair.

“It is not a test of any kind. It is a tool teachers have asked for. They wanted more consistency and reliability about the overall judgements they make in reading, writing and mathematics," she says.

"The tool responds to that need and will support professional teacher judgments.

"Teachers know their students best and the tool is designed to support their professional judgments – it does not replace those judgments.

Principals and teachers will also be able to use the tool to help teaching and learning in their schools. PaCT will help identify what professional, learning and development teachers may need.

“Work is being done to ensure that PaCT is approved and available as expected for schools. It is being introduced over 2013/2014 with full implementation in 2015,” says Phair.

Mozilla launches Firefox Send, an encrypted file transfer service
Mozille Firefox has launched a free encrypted file transfer service that allows people to securely share files from any web browser – not just Firefox.
Online attackers abusing Kiwis' generosity in wake of Chch tragedy
It doesn’t take some people long to abuse people’s kindness and generosity in a time of mourning.
Apple launches revamped iPad Air & iPad mini
Apple loves tinkering with its existing product lines and coming up with new ways to make things more powerful – and both the iPad Air and iPad mini seem to be no exception.
Epson innovations and Mercedes-AMG Petronas Motorsport
The world’s greatest motorsport event, the Formula One Grand Prix World Championship, descended on Melbourne’s Albert Park over the weekend for the first race of the 2019 season.
Tesla unveils the Model Y SUV
After much anticipation, Tesla unveiled the Model Y last week – a vehicle that is described as an all-electric, mid-size SUV that can seat seven adults – and the vehicle has a glass roof.
Preparation for Tokyo 2020 Olympics begins - with robots
The Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games are quickly approaching, but it won’t just be a sea of athletes and sports fans – now robots will make up a significant part of the fan experience.
Updated: NZ ISPs block internet footage of Christchurch shootings
2degrees, Spark, Vodafone and Vocus are now blocking any website that shows footage of the mosque shootings.
How AI could warn civilians before a volcanic eruption
Advance monitoring could lead to better disaster planning and evacuation warnings in the event of an eruption.